R v Antoine [2001]

Key Points To Note

• Cases involving defendants with severe mental or physical incapacities.

• Such cases pose an “inescapable public, moral and human rights dilemma” as noted by Lord Bingham.

2. Impact and Analysis:

• Legal Principle: Highlights the complexities and ethical considerations in dealing with defendants unfit for trial.

• Implications: This ruling underscores the ongoing challenge in balancing public safety, moral obligations, and human rights when dealing with incapacitated defendants, calling for nuanced legal and ethical approaches in such cases.